Best Restaurants in Star Idaho include craft pizza and cocktails, family-run Mexican food, and a steakhouse that serves breakfast. Also, all three sit along West State Street, so they’re easy to find in this small but fast-growing town.
Proof is a veteran-owned and locally owned restaurant and bar on West State Street. Its menu changes with the seasons and focuses on regional ingredients. For example, stone-baked pizzas, shared plates, and signature entrées are menu highlights. Additionally, the Proof Stone Bread arrives with lemon-pesto dipping sauce. Truffle fries make another popular starter. Meanwhile, the bar pours handcrafted cocktails, regional beer, and wine. Plus, a zero-proof cocktail menu gives non-drinkers fun options too.
El Mariachi Loco is a family-owned Mexican restaurant on West State Street. Inside, colorful decor gives the dining room a festive feel. The menu covers fajitas, enchiladas, chile rellenos, and carne asada. Also, portions are generous, so leftovers are common. Margaritas and chimichangas are frequent favorites among regulars. However, it’s often busy, so calling ahead helps. Because it’s open daily from 11 a.m., it works for lunch or dinner.
Rare Steakhouse sits just off Highway 16 and State Street. Formerly known as The Rustic Table, it took on a new name under new owners. Hand-cut steaks are the focus, cooked in beef tallow from Snake River Farms. As a result, the kitchen avoids seed oils entirely. Even so, it isn’t just for dinner, since doors open at 6 a.m. daily. For instance, chicken-fried steak and eggs is a popular breakfast order. In addition, diners often praise the Brussels sprouts.
Taphouse is the Star location of a longtime downtown Boise pub. As a sports bar, it pours around 45 drafts, and the beer list rotates often. Additionally, the kitchen serves classic pub fare with a local twist. For example, the Tin Shed Turkey sandwich and chicken tacos are popular picks. A heated, enclosed patio makes outdoor-style dining possible year-round. Plus, weekend brunch gives the place a relaxed morning crowd. Because games play on many screens, it’s a go-to spot on big sports days.
Sully’s is an Irish-style restaurant and lounge in downtown Star. Inside, the space is small, with a handful of tables and a large bar. However, the big back patio is the main draw, with picnic tables and heaters for colder months. Dogs are welcome outside, too. Meanwhile, the menu covers wings, burgers, barbecue, fish, and steak. The bison burger is a local favorite. In summer, regulars gather to throw horseshoes out back.
Star keeps dining casual, friendly, and close to State Street. Even so, these three spots give the town plenty of variety from breakfast through dinner.