Best Restaurants in Jerome Idaho

Best Restaurants in Jerome Idaho include loaded pub burgers, a classic family diner, and Mexican seafood. Also, all three sit close to South Lincoln Avenue and Main Street, just minutes from Interstate 84.

Fallback-Slide-1Fallback-Slide-1
Fallback-Slide-2Fallback-Slide-2
Fallback-Slide-3Fallback-Slide-3
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1Fallback-Mobile-Slide-1
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2Fallback-Mobile-Slide-2
Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3Fallback-Mobile-Slide-3

Fat Clarence’s Pub and Grub — Huge Burgers and Weekend Barbecue

Fat Clarence’s opened on South Lincoln Avenue in 2020. Since then, it has become one of Jerome’s most talked-about places to eat. Burgers start with hand-pattied Certified Angus beef, served with fresh-cut fries. For example, the Fat Clarence Style Burger stacks bacon, ham, Polish sausage, jalapeños, and a runny egg on a half-pound patty. Additionally, barbecue comes off the smoker on Fridays and Saturdays. Homemade potato chips make a fun side, too. Daily specials get posted on the restaurant’s Facebook page.

Choate’s Family Diner — A Main Street Diner With 1940s Roots

Choate’s sits on West Main Street, about a mile and a half from the freeway. The spot started as a burger stand back in the 1940s and has gone by many names since. Today, it’s a family-run diner serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Mornings bring classic diner breakfasts, while burgers fill the lunch crowd. Meanwhile, milkshakes have become the diner’s calling card. A drive-thru makes it handy for travelers in a hurry. However, it closes early on Saturdays and stays closed on Sundays.

La Costa Colima — Family-Run Mexican Seafood on Lincoln Avenue

La Costa Colima is a family-owned seafood restaurant on South Lincoln Avenue. Ceviche, shrimp tostadas, and octopus tostadas are standout orders. Also, whole fried fish appears on the menu, which surprises many first-time visitors. Classic Mexican plates are here too, like carne asada with big corn tortillas. The Molcajete Loco is a hearty pick for sharing. Plus, servings run large while prices stay reasonable. Because it’s open daily, it’s an easy dinner choice any night of the week.

Main Street Custom Cutting & Grill — Scratch-Made Burgers From a Family Butcher Shop

Main Street Custom Cutting & Grill sits on East Main Street downtown. A former long-haul truck driver and his family have run it since 2021. Everything is made from scratch, so the burger meat is ground in-house and the buns are baked fresh. Additionally, the menu covers grilled sandwiches, fries, tots, and a well-loved Reuben. For dessert, shakes, ice cream, and frozen lemonade are popular picks. Meanwhile, a butcher shop in back handles custom cutting and sells fresh, homegrown meat. However, it’s closed on weekends, so plan a weekday visit.

Garibaldi’s — Generous Mexican Plates and Margaritas

Garibaldi’s is a regional Mexican restaurant group that started in Twin Falls in 1994. Its Jerome location on South Lincoln Avenue was the second to open. The menu draws from Guadalajara, Michoacán, and Tex-Mex cooking. For example, enchiladas, burritos, fajitas, and chile verde are all regular favorites. Also, portions are generous, and the bar is known for its margaritas. Diners often mention the friendly service and clean dining room. Plus, it’s open daily, which makes it an easy pick for families.

Final Bite:

Jerome’s food scene is small but packed with local character. Even so, its family-run kitchens, from burger grills to Mexican favorites, give the town plenty of flavor.